Phraseology and iCloud, Dropbox, etc.

I anticipate the questions I will get asked most about Phraseology now that it is released are related to the omission of a syncing solution – specifically, iCloud and/or Dropbox. This was not an oversight, but an intentional omission in this first release – a calculated risk, I suppose. I wanted to focus on the unique aspects of the app, and not get bogged down reproducing the features of competing apps.

Phraseology supports the iOS Document Interaction model. It registers itself to handle plain text files, allowing you to import text files into the app from other apps that support export (such as the Dropbox app). It also allows you to export your text out to any apps that support receiving plain text files (such as the Dropbox app, and many other text editors). This was a baseline to me and I feel like any editor on the iPad should support this form of file exchange. The app also provides support for easy use of email, the clipboard and printing.

As I thought about implementation of other syncing solutions, and reviewed the way it has been done in other apps, I didn’t “feel” it. I realized that I didn’t want a traditional file manager. Some people are not going to like it, but old school files and folders didn’t feel right to me on the iPad and it seemed like that was where you had to go with Dropbox integration. Before reproduced the methods I saw in the other editors, I wanted to hear from users who valued the unique features of Phraseology and listen to what they really wanted. It may be Dropbox, and I may release support in an upcoming version.

As far as iCloud, I like it, but didn’t seem the immediate benefit of implementing it for an iPad only app. It doesn’t solve the same problem as Dropbox. Outside of the rare case of a person with two iPads, syncing to iCloud did not seem to make much sense until I have an iPhone or Mac app to go along with it.

If you like Phraseology, let me know what you think…I’m all ears and plan to deliver one or both or these options, if not others, in an upcoming release.

  • Anonymous

    Do you really need a Mac version for syncing to the Mac to make sense? What about just syncing to the Mac so that editing can continue there in one’s preferred desktop editor? I would use Phraseology on the iPad and BBEdit on the Mac.

    • http://agiletortoise.com Greg Pierce

      Just to make iCloud make sense. To participate in iCloud, your app has to have entitlements to the files to access them.  That is the attractive aspect of a Dropbox solution, for sure.

  • Peter

    I really like the features you have, but need Dropbox integration. Please add that.

  • http://wolfewithane.com Kevin Wolfe

    Greg,

    At the moment, I’m not seeing that iCloud is worth your dev efforts. It backs up files on iOS, but doesn’t make files accessible on the desktop like Dropbox does. I blog both personally and professionally and my workflow (at work) has been to write files in Markdown on my iPad, sync with Dropbox, open the files on Mac in Byline and copy code into the blog’s web editor. It would be great to be able to do that with Phraseology and Dropbox. (Currently I’m using Phraseology’s Copy feature and ClipTwin on iPad to transport text to the desktop and it’s been working smoothly.)

    I should note that many of the iOS Markdown editors are now having issues either with iOS5 or Dropbox syncing. As Phraseology seems very stable, it’s nice to find an app without either of these issues.

    I really have to applaud you on the linguistics analysis and Terminology integration. These are two unique and useful features that really sets Phraseology apart.

  • Pingback: A Review of Phraseology: The iPad App for Writers — 512 Pixels

  • http://blog.dikaryon.org Andrew

    My 2¢: I like the idea of this app a lot, especially Terminology integration and its paragraph rearranging capability, but I’m loathe to try out yet another iOS writing/markdown app unless it can sync with and search within a folder of .txt files on Dropbox. I pretty much live in nvAlt on my Mac, and I need everything I do elsewhere to sync without effort to that same folder.

    • Greg Pierce

      I’m committed to Dropbox support in the near future. I’ve already started on it.

  • Rui Nascimento

    Please add Dropbox integration.